All resources

Customer story

How Pour Some Sugar On It books custom cookie orders

A Trumbull home bakery takes custom cookie requests with photos, sends a price, and holds the date with a deposit, all on a website of its own.

Pour Some Sugar On It Trumbull, CT4 min read
Pour Some Sugar On It's Christmas cookies: Santa faces, gingerbread men, trees and plaid stockings, iced by hand on a marble counter
Live since Fall 2026

The challenge

Pour Some Sugar On It is a home bakery in Trumbull, CT. Every cookie is cut, baked and iced by hand to match the occasion, from baby showers and birthdays to school logos, concerts and corporate events.

Custom work doesn't fit a regular online menu. Each order starts as an idea, with a date, a theme, a few photos and a headcount, and the price depends on the design. A cart with fixed prices can't hold that, so orders like these usually live in messages and back-and-forth.

What changed

Cobble built her a website of her own at poursomesugaronitcookies.com, in her colors and her hand-iced style. Customers browse her gallery by occasion for ideas, then send a request with the date, the occasion, their ideas and photos, and how many they need.

She reviews each request and sends a price with a link to book. A 50% deposit holds the date, or customers can pay in full. Reminders go out by email and text a week before, with a link for the rest of the balance, and again the evening before with the pickup details.

Alongside the custom work, little batches she makes ahead go up as ready to order, for pickup on her next hand-over day in Trumbull or for delivery.

“If you can imagine it, I can cookie it.”
Pour Some Sugar On It · On her website

The result

Each request arrives with what she needs to price it, and the date is held by a deposit before she starts baking. From the gallery to the last reminder, customers see her name, her cookies and her prices.

For the holidays her site added a little fun too: a Design your own cookie page, where visitors ice and decorate a cookie on screen and send it to her cookie display for others to vote on.

Step by step

How a custom order works

One request, from her gallery to a booked date. Every screen is from her live site.

  1. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/gallery
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s gallery: If you can dream it, sky’s the limit, with occasions to browse
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    1Step 1

    The gallery

    Customers start with ideas. Her gallery is sorted by occasion, from birthdays and baby showers to holidays and corporate events.

  2. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/order
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s request form, Tell me about your event: the date, the occasion, and pickup, local delivery or shipping
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    2Step 2

    The request

    The request asks for the date, the occasion and how they'll get the cookies: pickup, local delivery or shipping.

  3. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/order
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s request form, Tell me what you’re imagining: a design note, photo uploads and inspiration from the gallery
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    3Step 3

    Ideas and photos

    Then the design, in their own words, with photos they upload or designs picked from her gallery.

  4. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/order
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s request form, How many cookies do you need: a dozen counter starting at 2 dozen
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    4Step 4

    How many

    By the dozen or by the cookie. Orders start at 2 dozen, at least 28 days ahead.

  5. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/how-it-works
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s How it works page: tell me about your event, then get your design and price
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    5Step 5

    Her price, then the deposit

    She reviews the request and sends a price with a link to book. A 50% deposit holds the date, reminders cover the rest, and the cookies are ready for pickup or delivery.

  6. poursomesugaronitcookies.com/menu
    Pour Some Sugar On It’s I’m Back cookies, ready to order: elf cookies with a name on each hat, $10
    A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com

    6Step 6

    Ready to order

    Small batches she makes ahead go up ready to order, like her I'm Back elf cookies, for pickup on her next hand-over day.

More on her site

More than an order form

Pour Some Sugar On It’s cookie maker: a round cookie with pink icing, a piped border and sprinkles, and the tools beside it: Shape, Scene, Icing, Text, Piping, Sprinkles, Toppers
A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com/design-a-cookie

A cookie maker on her site

Visitors design their own cookie right on her site: pick a shape, pour the icing, pipe lines and dots, add sprinkles and toppers, then send it in. Once a design is sent, the site points the way to a real custom order.

Pour Some Sugar On It’s cookie display: sent-in cookie designs, each with a Vote button and a share button
A real screen from poursomesugaronitcookies.com/cookie-wall · makers’ names hidden

The cookie display

Sent-in designs go on her cookie display, where anyone can vote for their favorites and share them. Beside it, her gallery shows her real work by occasion, so a fun design can lead to a custom order.

You found a hidden cookie!

Leave your name to claim your prize.

Illustration · the hunt ran in fall 2026

A hidden cookie hunt

For her launch, the site ran a hidden cookie hunt: one cookie tucked away on a page of her site, and the first people to find it got a free box of cookies. Once the prizes were claimed it was switched off, and it can come back any time from her dashboard.

cobblelocal.com/dashboard/website
The Cobble website editor with Pour Some Sugar On It’s home page open: pages and sections on the left, her site in the middle
Pour Some Sugar On It, in the Cobble website editor

Her site, changed by her

She changes her own site in the Cobble editor: her pages and sections, the words and photos, what shows and in what order. She publishes when it looks right.

Requests

Sample requests

  • Birthday · 2 dozenSat, Dec 12New request
  • Baby shower · 3 dozenSun, Dec 13Price sent
  • Logo cookies · 6 dozenFri, Dec 18Deposit paid
  • Christmas · 2 dozenSat, Dec 19Paid in full
Illustration with sample requests · never her customers

Requests, from her side

Every request lands in her Cobble dashboard with the date, the occasion, the photos and how many. She sets the price, and each request shows where it stands: a new request, a price sent, the deposit paid, the balance due, then paid in full.

Your store could be next.

Your own storefront, on Cobble POS or your Square account, with pickup, delivery and your regulars kept close. No subscriptions, no commissions.